New Google Search tools like AI Overviews and AI Mode, as well as emerging search engines like ChatGPT Search, are changing the way that people look up information and products online. In parallel with this shift towards AI-powered search, many marketers may have noticed a change – even a decline - in their organic performance. However, AI search tools may not be the sole reason for this shift.
A recent study found that text ads now make up a bigger portion of clicks on Google’s search results page, while organic click share dwindles. In other words, paid ads now take up more real estate on the SERP, and it’s having a real impact.
The top queries for four product categories – headphones, jeans, online games, and cards/ecards – were analyzed in order to see how click distribution between different types of paid and organic results changed over the course of a year. Additionally, the study looked at top domains in those categories
The share of traditional organic traffic (excluding things like AI Overviews) saw a significant decline of 11-23 percentage points YoY across every product category. Headphones saw the most significant decline, from 73% to 50%, while the organic click share for online games went from 95% to 84%. At the same time, text ads gained 7 to 13 percentage points, roughly tripling or quadrupling click share across all four product categories. In line with this increase, large brands like Amazon and Walmart saw significant gains in paid clicks.
Additionally, AI Overview presence increased in every product category, especially for online games and headphones, which both saw increases of about 30 percentage points.
If you’ve seen a recent change in your organic performance, the assumption might be that AI Overviews are your main competition. But this study indicates that Google’s increased focus on paid search ads is also contributing to a loss in organic visibility. As organic share declines, competition only intensifies as companies shift towards paid search in an attempt to recapture lost traffic. It’s important to keep this in mind when optimizing your organic and paid strategies.
--
Relevance Advisors wants to help your business succeed. Interested in learning more about Google Ads or organic search? Contact us today for a free consultation, or sign up for our weekly newsletter to receive free marketing tips and industry insights.